| A Creator is Born (Bronze) | Upload one creation to the WWE Community Creations |
| A Man Destined to Be a Champion (Bronze) | Win the final match at WWE UNIVERSE WrestleMania PPV (Single Player) |
| A Successful Cash In (Bronze) | Cash in Money In The Bank in WWE UNIVERSE and win using a Custom Superstar (Single Player) |
| Against the Odds (Bronze) | Win a ONE ON THREE FREE BRAWL (Single Player) |
| Arena Designer (Bronze) | Create one arena in Create-An-Arena. |
| Berserker (Silver) | Break 50 tables, ladders, or chairs in one session (Single Player) |
| Challenger (Bronze) | Win at least once on Hard difficulty or higher (Single Player) |
| COMEBACK!!! (Bronze) | Use COMEBACK ability to increase momentum to MAX (Single Player) |
| Creative With The Moves (Bronze) | Create a front, top rope and corner finishing move in Custom Finisher Move |
| Critic (Bronze) | Review 5 or more items on Community Creations |
| Custom Logo Wizard (Bronze) | Apply a Custom Logo to a Custom Superstar, Video, or Arena |
| Declaration of War (Bronze) | Interfere in an AI vs AI WWE UNIVERSE fight and beat one opponent (Single Player) |
| Destroyer (Bronze) | Inflict heavy damage to opponent's head, arms, and legs (Single Player) |
| Finished HERO Episode!!! (Silver) | Complete HERO episode in ROAD TO WrestleMania (Single Player) |
| Finished OUTSIDER Episode!! (Silver) | Complete OUTSIDER episode in ROAD TO WrestleMania (Single Player) |
| Finished VILLAIN Episode! (Silver) | Complete VILLAIN episode in ROAD TO WrestleMania (Single Player) |
| First Step of a Glorious Career (Bronze) | Win one Championship title in WWE UNIVERSE using a Custom Superstar (Single Player) |
| For Whom the Bell Tolls (Bronze) | Pin or submit Undertaker in the WrestleMania arena on Legend difficulty (Single Player) |
| Grand Slam Champion (Gold) | Win 5 championship titles in WWE UNIVERSE using a Custom Superstar (Single Player) |
| Holla! (Bronze) | Create your own show in WWE Universe |
| I Ain't Losing to Anyone! (Bronze) | Build momentum up to 100% in WWE UNIVERSE using a Custom Superstar (Single Player) |
| I Like Titles (Silver) | Win 3 championship titles in WWE UNIVERSE using a Custom Superstar (Single Player) |
| I'm Gonna be Champion (Bronze) | Become #1 Contender for a Championship in WWE UNIVERSE using a Custom Superstar (Single Player) |
| Legend Status Accomplishments (Gold) | Win 50 times on Hard difficulty or higher in one session (Single Player) |
| Look! Look at my Titantron! (Bronze) | Use a movie created in Custom Entrance Video in an entrance scene (Single Player) |
| Master of the Brawl (Silver) | Execute a Finisher against all 44 areas in FREE BRAWL (Single Player) |
| Merciless Attack (Bronze) | Injure an opponent in WWE UNIVERSE (Single Player) |
| Mr. Money in the Bank (Bronze) | Win the Money In The Bank match in WWE UNIVERSE using a Custom Superstar (Single Player) |
| My target at WrestleMania is...! (Bronze) | As WWE UNIVERSE Royal Rumble winner, participate in the Royal Rumble Winner's Event |
| Pandemonium (Bronze) | Interfere in an AI vs AI WWE UNIVERSE fight and beat all opponents (Single Player) |
| Platinum (Platinum) | Obtain all other Trophies. |
| Professional Material (Silver) | Win 20 times on Hard difficulty or higher in one session (Single Player) |
| Reach the Ropes! (Bronze) | Crawl to the ropes during a submission (Single Player) |
| Rolling Now! (Bronze) | Build momentum up to 75% in WWE UNIVERSE using a Custom Superstar (Single Player) |
| Start as a Pro (Bronze) | Win using a Custom Superstar in WWE UNIVERSE (Single Player) |
| Start Online NXT! (Bronze) | Play in an Online match (Player match/Ranked match) |
| Submission Specialist (Silver) | Win 20 times with submissions in one session (Single Player) |
| Superstar Contender (Bronze) | Win a Superstar match at the WWE UNIVERSE Draft Event (Single Player) |
| Thank You Edge (Bronze) | Win 37 times with Edge in one session (Single Player) |
| That's gotta hurt! (Bronze) | Win a FREE BRAWL by throwing your opponent through the window (Single Player) |
| The Art of Submission (Bronze) | Win by applying a submission to a heavily damaged body part (Single Player) |
| The Birth of a Historic Tag Team (Bronze) | Win or defend one Tag Team Championship in WWE UNIVERSE using a Custom Superstar (Single Player) |
| The WWE Arrives at a New Arena! (Bronze) | Hold an Exhibition at a Custom Arena (Single Player) |
| This Combo is Lethal! (Silver) | Perform a Wake-Up taunt, hit your finisher, and then win via pinfall (Single Player) |
| Unique Original Story (Bronze) | Create a story that includes a Custom Superstar or Custom Arena |
| Well Scouted (Bronze) | Reverse an opponent's finishing move (Single Player) |
| Wildman of the Ring (Bronze) | Break 20 tables, ladders, or chairs in one session (Single Player) |
| Worked the Limb (Bronze) | Use the limb targeting system to attack the same part 10 times in one match (Single Player) |
| WrestleMania's My Destiny! (Silver) | Win a Royal Rumble match at Royal Rumble PPV in WWE UNIVERSE (Single Player) |
| You've Got Fans! (Silver) | Content you uploaded to Community Creations is downloaded 5 or more times by other players |
